Friday, November 20, 2026

Insight: Thanksgiving Family Feud

By Ed Pierce
Managing Editor


Celebrating Thanksgiving with my family through the decades produces many cherished and wonderful memories for me although there were some holidays that even the deepest forms of hypnosis or years of intense psychotherapy could never me make me forget.

The feuding sisters on Thanksgiving Day were Harriett Pierce,
left, and her older sister Berniece Rogers.
PHOTO BY ED PIERCE  
For years I longed to have grown up in a home with a loving family who all got along but unfortunately, I came to expect that animosity and snide remarks while the turkey was carved was par for the course in our household. When you are a child in a home with parents constantly bickering and arguing, Thanksgiving and the holiday season were hardly special.

As a child, I recall visiting the homes of relatives on Thanksgiving in 1960 when a heated political discussion about John F. Kennedy winning the U.S. presidential election over Richard Nixon turned into uppercuts and a wrestling match on the front porch. On another occasion, my parents had a less than friendly exchange about whether a portable television set should be wheeled into the dining room to watch a football game during Thanksgiving dinner.

Despite the passing of time, I found that some things hadn’t changed very much when I returned home as an adult after years of studying at college, serving in the military and establishing my career more than 2,000 miles away.

In 1993, my mother invited her older sister and me to Thanksgiving dinner along with one of her friends from work and what happened that day remains indelibly etched in my brain forever.

She had spent all day preparing a full Thanksgiving meal of roasted turkey, mashed potatoes, gravy, yams, green bean casserole, stuffing, cranberry sauce, dinner rolls and pumpkin pie. After I carved the turkey, we all sat down to consume a great meal.

To understand and detail the relationship between my mother and her sister takes some explanation. They had grown up in foster care during the Great Depression after their mother had died when they were young. Each sister survived, but it jaded them.

My aunt had served in the Women's Army Auxiliary Corps in World War II and was rather worldly before marrying and becoming a born-again Christian. My mother had gotten married at 18, then became a divorced single mother in the late 1940s whose sole goal was to marry a successful man and live in a fine house.

Each sister tried to constantly outdo each other but by that Thanksgiving Day in 1993, they were aging widows who lived about two miles away from each other. My mother had purchased her own home and a mobile home for my aunt and seemed to enjoy bringing that up to her frequently. Their relationship was anything but loving.

So, as we filled our plates that day and started to eat, my mother asked my aunt what she wanted for Christmas. She answered her by saying “You never buy me what I ask for anyways.”

With that my mother lost her temper and told her sister to leave, right there in the middle of the Thanksgiving meal. My aunt stormed out of the house, got in her car, backed out of the driveway and making sure that my mother was watching her, she honked her horn and stuck out her tongue at her.

They didn’t speak for weeks afterward. It left me in an awkward position of having to listen to each one of them and try and make peace between them. My aunt would drive over to my mother’s neighborhood, slowly cruise past her house and make a crude gesture at her if my mother was outside at the time. 

My mother would then call every other relative she could think of and tell them how her sister acted toward her. Several months into this petty feud, my mother would drive through my aunt’s mobile home park and make a crude gesture if she saw her outside.

They each would go to the same restaurant several times a week for breakfast and sit at adjoining tables. They would both tell stories to the waitress about how horrible that their sister treated them, They were sitting less than 15 feet apart from each other and could hear what each other was saying. They would pass each other in the grocery aisle, ignore each other, and look the other way.

Neither was willing to give an inch or try to settle their differences.

That all ended though when my aunt suddenly fell and was in the hospital after breaking her hip. My mother seemed to forget all about the feud and stepped in to take my aunt whatever she needed while she was in the hospital. They became close again and would visit at least once a week.

Just a year later in 1994, both sisters were back at my mother’s dining table gathered for Thanksgiving. This time each sister laughed off what had happened previously on Thanksgiving Day and that spirit of family unity lasted until the next summer and the next argument between them, followed by months of not talking to each other.

For those of you planning a peaceful loving family gathering on this Thanksgiving Day, count your blessings. Not everyone’s so fortunate. <

No comments:

Post a Comment