![]() |
| The bronze plaque for a Civil War veteran's statue from New Hampshire went missing for 83 years before it was discovered in an old cellar hole 51 miles away and returned. PHOTO BY ED PIERCE |
Loammi Bean was a 37-year-old farmer serving in the 8th New Hampshire Volunteer Regiment on Oct. 27, 1862 when his unit confronted Confederate forces near a site called Georgia Landing, close to an abandoned sugar refinery in Tigonsville, Louisiana. Bean was a private with less than a year of military experience when he was killed in action that day and his remains were buried in an unmarked grave near the battlefield.
His daughter, Nellie Bean Zebley, was about 14 when her father Loammi died and she grew up in very humble circumstances. Zebley married a wealthy banker from New York City but chose to live in Laconia, New Hampshire. She deeply missed her father and in 1894, Zebley paid to have an elaborate cast iron statue with a fountain and bronze memorial plaque at its base dedicated to her late father and installed at a prominent location near Lake Winnipesaukee close to where Civil War veterans’ groups would gather every summer for reunions.
Nellie’s health began to decline by the time she was in her late 70s, and she hired a private nurse by the name of Josie Swain of Warren, New Hampshire to care for her in her home in Laconia until she passed away at the age of 80 in 1928.
Now here’s where the story gets weird.
In the early evening of July 24, 1931, violent thunderstorms ripped through Laconia and a bolt of lightning struck the Loammi Bean statue, shattering it and sending pieces of it flying nearby. When Laconia residents realized what had happened, they ran to the statue site and started gathering up and collecting pieces of the demolished statue as souvenirs. The next day’s edition of the daily newspaper in Laconia reported that people were seen carrying off the statue’s arms, hands, legs and whatever else they could find, including the memorial plaque for Loammi Bean.
The statue was not rebuilt, but some members of the town government sought to recover the bronze plaque and give it to Nellie’s surviving family. That never happened and after a few years during the Great Depression, the mystery of the missing plaque faded slowly into history.
Some 47 years later in 1978, Robert and Sylvia Newton discovered a burned-out old farmhouse cellar on their property in Warren, New Hampshire. Robert had spotted something shiny when he attempted to illuminate down the cellar hole with a flashlight. He was able to reach down and grab the shiny object. Once the dust was cleared away, that object turned out to be a bronze plaque dedicated to a Civil War soldier, Loammi Bean of Laconia.
The Newtons then sat down and wrote a letter to the City of Laconia describing the object they had found on their property. They included a scroll etching of the plaque, put the letter and the scroll in a large manila envelope and mailed it off, hoping to receive a reply right away.
Once the envelope was received by the city, apparently nobody there knew what to do with the information inside and the city clerk’s office set it aside in a filing cabinet. It sat there for another 36 years when it was placed into a box and given to the city’s historical society.
The historical society’s executive director looked over the letter and the etched scroll and quickly realized it was about the missing Loammi Bean plaque. She set out to find out if the Newtons still lived in Warren and if they still had the plaque.
The answer she found was that they were indeed still alive and still living at the same home in Warren, New Hampshire. And yes, they still had the plaque.
The best guess put forward to solve the mystery by the historical society’s executive director was that sometime after lightning struck the Loammi Bean statue in 1931, someone tried to return the plaque to the Zebley and the Bean family, but she was dead and they were unable to do that. So, the person who recovered the plaque gave it to Zebley’s nurse Swain before she had moved back to Warren from Laconia.
But how the plaque wound up in the cellar hole prior to its discovery by the Newtons is also an enigma. The Newtons lived more than four miles away from where Swain lived with her family before her death in 1947.
In 2014, the Newtons loaned the plaque to the City of Laconia where it was displayed at the public library in an exhibition dedicated to military veterans. Descendants of Zebley living in Laconia were able to hold the plaque and said they were grateful to be able to do that because it linked a relic of the past with their own family’s history.
I’ve covered many unusual stories during my career, but this ranks right up there. <






