Managing Editor
When my mother died at the age of 95 in August 2018, I thought she had shared everything about her family with me before leaving the earthly plane of existence.
Several of the newspaper stories are shown detailing previously unknown information about one of Ed Pierce's late relatives. COURTESY PHOTO |
A story passed down through the generations of our family is that one of those Scottish immigrants by the name of James Rutherford McIntosh first heard about a booming economy in Rochester, New York, about 145 miles away from his home in Dundas, Ontario in 1855. It seems Rochester’s textile and flour mills were a huge economic success and James R. McIntosh wanted to be a part of that. He successfully applied to immigrate to America, moved to Rochester and found steady employment there.
He eventually married an Irish immigrant to the United States, Helen Agnes Duffy, and they had six children, one of whom was my great-grandmother, Harriett McIntosh, who died at 65 in 1939 in Rochester. My mother, Harriett Baker, was named after her and that was the story I was familiar with.
But I recently learned several things about one of my great-grandmother’s sisters that I was never told by my mother and for the life of me, I can’t say why she never mentioned them.
For part of my ancestral research, I also have had a subscription to newspapers.com for many years. On occasion I have used it to find old clippings of newspaper stories I have written but didn’t save from the 1970s and 1980s. While on Christmas break last month, I decided to see how far back their files went and looked up my great-grandmother’s obituary in the Rochester newspaper from 1939. It was easily found. In that obituary it listed her husband, her children, her grandchildren and her surviving brother, James R. McIntosh Jr., and surviving sister, Anna Duffy Sill.
I wanted to know more about James R. McIntosh Jr. but noticed that he had died in 1948. Several news stories were posted though about his sister, Anna Sill, and that’s where I surprisingly discovered facts I had never heard before about my relatives.
The first news story I read was from 1936 and it was an obituary for Anna’s husband, Julius Sill. It said Anna and Julius did not have children, only nieces and nephews. Then I saw in a clipping from Jan. 22, 1942 that Anna D. Sill, 62 at the time, testified in a court trial in Rochester about being assaulted in her home by a man she was renting a room to. Apparently, she had converted her home into a rooming house following her husband’s death and during an argument with a man renting a room there about his drinking, he struck her over the head with a hammer.
She was taken to the hospital and was treated for eight lacerations to her scalp requiring 30 stitches. The man was on trial for second degree assault and his defense was that he wasn’t responsible for his actions because he was drunk stemming from being a single parent after his wife had died. The judge found him guilty and sentenced him to three years in prison for assaulting my great-great-aunt Anna Sill.
The bombshell news clipping I found was from the Dec. 8, 1954 edition of the newspaper though. In the early morning hours of Dec. 7, 1954, a neighbor going to work living near Anna Sill noticed her house was on fire. He awakened his next-door neighbors, one of whom was home on leave from the U.S. Army. They tried to enter Ann’s home through the front door where she was living alone but were turned back by intense heat, flames and dense smoke. They also tried to get in through several windows and a side door but were driven back by flames.
When the fire department arrived on the scene, the home could not be saved. The Fire Battalion Chief said the house was “like a furnace.”
Hours later when the fire was extinguished and firefighters were sifting through the rubble, they found Anna’s corpse in the basement laundry room. The city mortician said she had been trying to reach the front door of her home crossing the living room to escape the blaze. Intense heat caused the chimney and a wall to fall down in the living room. The living room floor then collapsed into the basement and carried Anna to her death with it.
I was just a year old at the time and had never heard about any of these events growing up. In fact, I only heard Anna’s name mentioned once by my mother that I can recall.
Finding these stories was like discovering secrets from beyond the grave. <